Ooma vs MagicJack: Price & Features Comparison 2023

Our research shows that Ooma is better than MagicJack, thanks to its larger feature catalog, robust customer support, and popularity amongst users. There are some perks for both though, so read on to learn more about these two VoIP providers.

While MagicJack pricing is a bit cheaper at first, you'll likely end up paying more for additional features. Unless you're a team of under 5 people, and not looking to grow, Ooma will work out to be better value, and allow for more streamlined business growth with its more extensive feature set and 24/7 support offered.

Ooma also frequently offers low-cost package deals, including hardware bundles along with the VoIP software, which is helpful if you're a small business with a smaller budget.

Read on to see exactly what you get with each provider, and to find out which will suit your business best. Or, cut to the chase and get a VoIP price quote now to make sure you get the best deal for your business.

Ooma vs MagicJack: Which VoIP Service Is Better?

Side-by-side, it's easy to see that Ooma offers more features than MagicJack, as well as other factors that may sway the undecided, such as international call rates and 24/7 support.

On this page:

• Which VoIP Service is Better?
• Ooma Pricing vs MagicJack Pricing
• How We Compared MagicJack and Ooma
• Ooma vs MagicJack: Verdict
• Frequently Asked Questions

Best for Business Features – Winner: Ooma

When it comes to features, Ooma has the edge over MagicJack. Not only does Ooma have a larger feature set, but it also includes the vast majority of them as standard. While Ooma offers two pricing tiers, MagicJack has just one, with the advanced features charged as optional extras per feature, including auto attendant (a virtual assistant) which costs an added $10/month.

Accordingly, our research found that Ooma absolutely scores higher when it comes to features, netting a 4.1/5, which is considerably higher than the 2.1/5 from MagicJack.

External connections

Integrations can be a huge deciding factor when choosing a new telephone system. After all, being able to connect your phone service to existing components of your business and have them seamlessly work in unison is a big advantage.

In this regard, Ooma can integrate with far more services than MagicJack, like CRM, web conferencing, and live chat software. This helped Ooma secure a respectable 2.7/5 for external connections, whereas MagicJack had one of the lowest scores in our research at only 1.1/5.

Equipment

When it comes to equipment, both services will sell you VoIP compatible desk phones so that you can make use of the service. Here the two companies are tied they both rely on Yealink model VoIP phones, offering a range of models at various prices. Yealink brand phones are tried and tested, and a good choice for businesses wanting to invest in a VoIP infrastructure.

Mobile App

As you’d expect, both Ooma and MagicJack provide mobile apps on Android and iOS devices. Both do well in terms of ratings by customers on both the Apple store and Google Play store.

However, it’s Ooma’s apps that are clearly more popular, and more highly rated. In fact, this helped Ooma secure a customer score of 4.4/5, which is far better than MagicJack at only 1.7/5 in our research.

The Ooma mobile app

The MagicJack business mobile app

Best for Value – Winner: Ooma

It’s a close call between Ooma and MagicJack when it comes to value. MagicJack should be the runaway winner when you compare the monthly costs. However, a less robust selection of features and additional costs mean that MagicJack’s seemingly cheap price could quickly rise, while Ooma includes pretty much everything you might need from the off.

Ooma pricing vs MagicJack pricing

Ooma offers three different pricing plans, whereas MagicJack only offers a single pricing plan. Ooma has the entry level Ooma Office, priced at $19.95/month/user, the more feature laden Ooma Office Pro, priced at $24.95/month/user, and the even more robust Ooma Office Pro Plus, priced at $29.95/month/user. MagicJack just offers a single MagicJack for Business plan that is priced at $15.99/month/user.

MagicJack also offers a bunch of advanced features like auto-attendant and virtual fax for an additional fee of between $5 and $10 per month, whereas Ooma includes these features for free.

As you can tell, MagicJack is clearly more affordable, with its only plan costing less than the cheapest Ooma plan, hands down. However, you have to consider what you get for the money, particularly if you plan on utilizing those additional features that cost more from MagicJack. Simply put, if you have any plans to scale, paying a bit extra now for Ooma will be a lifesaver down the road.

Read our Ooma review for a full breakdown

Ooma vs MagicJack Customer Service: Winner – Ooma

We'll cut to the chase on this one: Ooma has way better customer support than MagicJack and it's not even close. Our research scored Ooma's customer support highly at 4.5/5, which was in the top three for highest in all of our data. MagicJack, on the other, scored the lowest in our research, scoring an unimpressive 2.1/5, which is not great.

Right out of the gate, Ooma offers 24/7 live chat and phone support for all of its plans, as well as knowledge base and user forums available to help yourself when you can. MagicJack offers literally none of that, providing only email and phone support on weekdays from 8:30am to 6:30pm. Suffice it to say, Ooma wins when it comes to customer service over MagicJack.

User Experience

Take a look at online reviews of both Ooma and MagicJack, and you may not be too impressed. On the review site ‘Trustpilot, Ooma score a 1.7 out of 5, with 1,119 reviews. MagicJack don’t do much better, with a rating of 2.1, although it’s worth noting that it only has 21 reviews in total.

So what are the issues? A look at the reviews for Ooma suggest some users experience issues cancelling their service. For MagicJack, it’s billing and service issues.

If we’re being honest, there are few VoIP providers that achieve high customer ratings on Trustpilot. A look at two more major providers, RingCentral and Vonage, show scores of 2.4 and 1.8 respectively. The reality is, most users are perfectly happy with their service, and don't feel the need to leave a review.

What's more, the average score method doesn't accurately reflect the most common user experience of the reviews that are left. Among Ooma's reviews are plenty of customers who are very happy with their service, for example. In fact, 84% of Ooma review respondents have left a five star rating that’s 937 out of those 1,119 reviews.

Setup Options

Both Ooma and MagicJack are refreshingly simple systems to set up. In the case of Ooma, the company states that it will take around 20 minutes to set up your device and connect to the service. If you get stuck, there’s customer support on hand too.

As for MagicJack, it’s a similar situation (although the company is adamant it can have you up and running in an impressive 10 minutes), especially if you choose to bypass a physical phone and connect through the mobile app instead.

Either way, both providers are able to promise a simple setup, and users shouldn’t find any worrying barriers with either of them.

Support Options

Ooma

• Live chat (24/7)
• Set-up Assistant
• Phone support (5am PT to 5pm PT)
• Online tools
• Forums

MagicJack

• Phone support (Mon – Fri, 8:30am to 6:30pm EST)
• Email
• Knowledge base

As you’d expect, both Ooma and MagicJack offer a good range of support options, with email and telephone support all available.

However, it’s Ooma that offers more options, with 24/7 live chat and forums complementing the usual platforms, as well as longer opening hours for its telephone support making it the clear winner when it comes to customer service.

Best for International Calling

It's fairly standard for VoIP providers to include domestic calls in their packages, and both Ooma and MagicJack have done just that. However, while they both cover the US and Canada, Ooma also includes Mexico in its package free of charge, while these calls with MagicJack will cost you 3.8¢ per minute. Calls to Puerto Rico, using Ooma, are free as well.

When it comes to other international calls, Ooma really takes the lead. As you can see from the selection of prices below, calls to other countries often cost just a fraction of what MagicJack charge. If you're a business looking to do a lot of business overseas, Ooma is by far the most attractive option.

Another popular alternative is Google Voice. See how it stacks up against Ooma.

Ooma vs MagicJack: Voice Quality

VoIP has come a long way since its inception, and today it's almost impossible for the average caller to tell the difference between an internet-based call and a traditional analogue one.

Sound quality plays an important part for a provider, and can make or break a business if call quality isn't up to scratch, customers will simply go elsewhere.

It's something that Ooma takes seriously, so much so that it regularly sends out its own surveys to customers. In its most recent survey, 76% of Ooma Office users rated its sound quality as eight or higher on a scale of 1 to 10.  Less than three percent of users reported experiencing call quality issues regularly.

There's no similar study from MagicJack (at least one they share publicly), but we do know that the company serves over 250,000 businesses, so it's clearly doing something right.

How We Compared MagicJack and Ooma

You've heard a lot about scores and research in this guide, but how exactly are we coming up with these rankings for VoIP providers? Hopefully it makes you feel a bit better to know that we put each VoIP provider through rigorous testing to make sure we are offering our readers the most helpful information about business tools like Ooma and MagicJack. Here are the metrics by which we judged these two VoIP providers against each other:

• Value – How affordable the pricing plans are and whether they offer unlimited domestic and international minutes
• External connections – What kind of other business resources can integrate with the provider
• Features – How large the feature catalog is for a particular provider
• Customer support – What kind of hours the support team keeps and how many channels they can be reached on
• Security – Whether a provider offers security measures like password rules, user permissions, multi-factor authentication, and encryption
• Scalability – Whether a provider offers features that can grow with your businesses like ring groups and call barge
• Customer score – An aggregate score of ratings and reviews across other websites that show how popular a provider is with actual users

For more information about how Tech.co measures business software against other competitors, take a look at our research guide to learn as much as possible about our process.

Ooma vs MagicJack Frequently Asked Questions